top of page
  • Writer's pictureJessica Brugger

Choosing the Perfect Kitchen Countertop: A Comprehensive Guide

If you're gearing up for a kitchen renovation or simply dreaming of countertop upgrades, you've landed in the perfect spot. Today, we're taking a deep dive into the world of kitchen countertop materials. From trendy porcelain to timeless marble, we'll break it down with the nitty-gritty details, including their quirks, installation costs, pricing comparisons, durability tales, and the myriad of finish options. So, grab a cup of coffee... or wine and read on.

Andrea Rugg

1. Porcelain Countertops:

This is not the tile countertops of yesteryear. Porcelain is having a surge as a great option for kitchen countertops. Largely based on durability and ease.


  • Durability: Picture this: a boisterous family breakfast with pancakes sizzling on the griddle. Porcelain won't flinch against the heat or the batter spills—it's built tough!

  • Low Maintenance: Forget about high-maintenance relationships; porcelain won't burden you with sealing rituals. A quick wipe-down is all it needs.

  • Versatility: Just like your favorite pair of jeans, porcelain comes in various shades and patterns to fit any kitchen style. It's like the chameleon of countertops!


  • Pricey Adventures: While porcelain is a star, it can be a high-end diva in the price department.

  • Installation Intricacies: Installing large porcelain slabs need the finesse of seasoned pros. The sheets are big and fragile prior to installation, a job for the pros.

David Carmack

2. Soapstone Countertops:

Full disclosure- We chose Soapstone in one of our personal kitchen renovations. Everyone tried to talk us out of this choice along the way, but we persisted, and love them to this day. Don't be afraid of a bit of maintenance for the right choice for you. In my opinion, much like marble there is nothing like the color, texture and finish of natural soapstone.


  • Timeless Elegance: Imagine a cozy candlelit dinner in your kitchen—the gentle glow accentuates the natural beauty of soapstone. It's warm, its elegant, its timeless, it’s the Audrey Hepburn of countertops.

  • Heat Resistance: If you're a baking aficionado, soapstone loves your hot-from-the-oven pies and casseroles.

  • Easy Repair: Minor scratches or stains? No worries, a little sanding, and soapstone is back to its elegant self.


  • Durability: Soapstone is a softer material than Quartz, but not as delicate as marble. You'll want to be comfortable with a level of patina happening with this material.

  • Maintenance Date: Soapstone craves some TLC in the form of periodic oiling to maintain its sheen.

  • Color Palette: Soapstone typically rocks in shades of gray or black, with some green or pink hues. It isn't the most vibrant option for a countertop.

3. Quartz Countertops:

Quartz has been the leading material for countertops for years, largely due to its versatility and durability. We installed quartz in our current home, and it is all about durability. With two kids and a family that regularly cooks, we knew we needed to prioritize ease and durability.


  • Stain Resistant: Quartz is like the superhero of stain resistance. Spills, splatters, and messes are all easy to clean up!

  • Variety Galore: Imagine having an all-you-can-eat buffet of colors and patterns. Quartz caters to every taste.

  • No-Fuss Clean-Up: Got a sticky situation? A little soap and water and quartz is ready for another round.


  • Budget Rollercoaster: Prices for quartz countertops vary wildly. You can find something for every budget, but some choices can break the bank.

  • Heat Advisory: While quartz is durable, it's not a fan of hot pots and pans. Keep those coasters handy!

  • Man Made: The pros and cons are largely due to the fact that this is a man-made product. There has been some press in the last year about this not being as durable as originally presented as well as health concerns for those workers that manufacture these slabs.

4. Quartzite Countertops:

Quartzite is a natural stone, like Marble, that is mostly comprised of you guessed it... Quartz. Could this be the more durable alternative to Marble and Soapstone if you want a natural stone? I sure think so.


  • Natural Beauty Show: Quartzite showcases the raw beauty of Mother Nature herself.

  • Built Tough: Resistant to both heat and scratches, it's ready for your family uses.

  • Colors Galore: With a wide range of colors and veining patterns, quartzite offers a kaleidoscope of choices.


  • Sealing Rituals: To keep its appeal, quartzite needs occasional sealing. Think of it as giving your countertop a little spa day.

  • Price Tag: Be prepared; quartzite often resides in the upper price echelons.

5. Marble Countertops: Hey classic surface option- your dramatic (in all the ways), but worth it!


  • Timeless Elegance Redux: Marble doesn't age—it's like the James Bond of the kitchen world.

  • Cool and Chic: Perfect for those who love rolling out dough or just want to keep things cool and classic.

  • Nature's Art: Every marble slab is a unique masterpiece; no two are alike.


  • Durability: Marble is another one that your contractor will likely try to talk you out of. I think it’s a terrific option- IF you are comfortable with the nuances of this material. It is going to stain, etch and chip. It's a patina, there are ways to re polish or hone it, but it’s definitely an important consideration.

  • High-Maintenances: Marble can be a bit needy, requiring regular sealing to fend off stains and etching.

  • Premium Price: The elegance of marble comes with a price tag to match.

Jared Kuzia

Pricing Comparison:

  • Porcelain: $$ - $$$

  • Soapstone: $$$ - $$$$

  • Quartz: $$$ - $$$$$

  • Quartzite: $$$ - $$$$$

  • Marble: $$$$ - $$$$$

Finish Options:

The finish of your surface can't be overlooked. The finish says as much about the feeling of the space as the material does. Don't miss this important detail!

  • Polished: For that glossy, reflective look.

  • Honed: Embrace the matte, smooth finish.

  • Leathered: Get texture with a low-gloss appeal.

Picking the perfect kitchen countertop isn't just about aesthetics; it's a practical decision too. Your budget, maintenance preferences, and kitchen activities all come into play. Whether you go for the resilient porcelain, the timeless charm of marble, or something in between, each material has its unique character. So, in the end, it's not just about countertops; it's about creating a kitchen that truly reflects your style and personality. Cheers to your design adventures, and may your kitchen always be the heart of your home!

11 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page